Best Hamburger in Manhattan

Based on 0 critic and audience reviews analyzed across Manhattan

Smash, classic, or gourmet — the humble hamburger is Manhattan's ultimate comfort food.

hamburger
Make it at home →
2026 Best Dish Honorees
View all rankings →
#1
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Aunt Jake's

1555 2nd Ave, New York, NY, 10028
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

An Upper East Side Italian spot whose smash burger is a sleeper hit — thin, crispy-edged patties with melted American cheese, pickles, and a toasted bun that has earned a cult following.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
93%
380 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#2
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Nowon East Village

507 E 6th St, New York, NY, 10009
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

An East Village Korean-American spot whose bulgogi-spiced burger features a juicy patty with gochujang aioli and pickled vegetables — a bold, flavorful fusion that stands apart.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
92%
508 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#3
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Raoul's

180 Prince St, New York, NY 10012
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

The SoHo French bistro whose off-menu burger is a legendary secret — a dry-aged patty on a sesame bun with caramelized onions that attracts industry insiders and in-the-know diners.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
91%
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#4
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's Kitchen

311 West 48th St, New York, NY, 10019
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

The Hell's Kitchen pizzeria whose Le Big Matt burger features two smashed patties with special sauce and American cheese — a worthy rival to its acclaimed Detroit-style pies.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
90%
185 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#5
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Upland

345 Park Ave S, New York, NY, 10010
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A Flatiron New American restaurant whose burger features a well-seasoned, perfectly cooked patty with creative toppings that reflect the kitchen's California-meets-New York sensibility.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
89%
1340 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#6
hamburger
Hamburgerat

JG Melon

1291 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10021
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

The Upper East Side tavern whose no-frills cheeseburger — a thin, well-seared patty with American cheese on a toasted bun — has been a neighborhood institution for decades.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
89%
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#7
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Emily

35 Downing St, New York, NY, 10014
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A West Village pizzeria whose burger rivals its acclaimed pies — a juicy, well-charred patty with melted cheese and a soft bun that makes it one of the best in downtown Manhattan.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
87%
1155 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#8
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Minetta Tavern

113 Macdougal St, New York, NY, 10012
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

The MacDougal Street bistro whose Black Label burger — a dry-aged blend of prime cuts — is one of the most celebrated (and expensive) burgers in America.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
87%
2652 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#9
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Corner Bistro

94 A Ave A, New York, NY, 10009
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

The East Village dive bar whose bare-bones burger has been the standard for cheap, satisfying late-night eats since 1961 — a thick patty with no frills and no apologies.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
86%
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#10
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Parm

248 Mulberry St, New York, NY, 10012
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

The Nolita red-sauce joint whose cheeseburger is a well-kept secret — a juicy, well-seasoned patty that channels classic American diner style.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
85%
1027 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
On the Rise
#11
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Mother's Ruin

18 Spring St, New York, NY, 10012
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A Nolita cocktail bar whose burger is an unexpectedly excellent bar bite — a well-seared patty with quality toppings that surprises given the cocktail-forward setting.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
84%
532 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#12
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Cubby's

630 10th Ave, Manhattan, NY, 10036
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A Hell's Kitchen neighborhood spot serving a straightforward, well-made burger with a juicy patty, fresh toppings, and a toasted bun in a casual, friendly setting.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
84%
103 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#13
hamburger
Hamburgerat

P.J. Clarke's

915 Third Ave, New York, NY, 10022
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

The legendary Midtown saloon since 1884, whose classic burger — a thick, juicy patty served on a simple bun — has been a New York institution for over a century.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
81%
1141 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#14
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Old John's Diner

148 W 67th St, New York, NY, 10023
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

An Upper West Side diner whose honest, well-made burger satisfies the neighborhood craving for a classic American cheeseburger without pretension.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
80%
309 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#15
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Schnipper's

570 Lexington Ave, New York, NY, 10022
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A Midtown quick-service spot whose burger features a well-seasoned patty with crispy fries — a solid, reliable lunch option among the Lexington Avenue office towers.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
80%
435 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#16
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Lovely Day

196 Elizabeth St, New York, NY, 10012
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A Nolita café with a pan-Asian menu whose burger is an off-script crowd-pleaser — a juicy patty with creative toppings in a laid-back, eclectic setting.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
79%
420 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#17
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Lure Fishbar

142 Mercer St, New York, NY, 10012
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A SoHo seafood brasserie whose burger features a high-quality beef patty with elegant toppings, served in a stylish Mercer Street dining room.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
79%
2077 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#18
hamburger
Hamburgerat

Virgil's Real BBQ - NYC

152 W 44th St, New York, NY, 10036
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A Times Square BBQ spot whose smoked burger combines smoky, well-seasoned beef with BBQ-inflected toppings — a hearty pick from their meat-heavy menu.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
77%
2101 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#19
hamburger
Hamburgerat

ABC Kitchen

35 E 18th St, New York, NY, 10003
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

Jean-Georges Vongerichten's Flatiron farm-to-table restaurant, where the grass-fed burger reflects a commitment to quality ingredients and seasonal, thoughtful preparation.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
77%
3306 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
hamburger
Been on a hamburger crawl?

Rate each spot to track your progress and build your personal ranking.

Behind the Dish
Aunt Jake's
#1 Hamburger in Manhattan
Coming Soon

Full Rankings at a Glance

#RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreKnown For
1Aunt Jake'sUpper East Side$$93%An Upper East Side Italian spot whose smash burger is a sleeper hit — thin, c...
2Nowon East VillageNew York$$$92%An East Village Korean-American spot whose bulgogi-spiced burger features a j...
3Raoul'sNew York91%The SoHo French bistro whose off-menu burger is a legendary secret — a dry-ag...
4Emmy Squared Pizza - Hell's KitchenNew York90%The Hell's Kitchen pizzeria whose Le Big Matt burger features two smashed pat...
5UplandNew York$$$89%A Flatiron New American restaurant whose burger features a well-seasoned, per...
6JG MelonNew York89%The Upper East Side tavern whose no-frills cheeseburger — a thin, well-seared...
7EmilyNew York$$87%A West Village pizzeria whose burger rivals its acclaimed pies — a juicy, wel...
8Minetta TavernNew York$$$87%The MacDougal Street bistro whose Black Label burger — a dry-aged blend of pr...
9Corner BistroNew York86%The East Village dive bar whose bare-bones burger has been the standard for c...
10ParmNew York$$85%The Nolita red-sauce joint whose cheeseburger is a well-kept secret — a juicy...
11Mother's RuinNew York$$84%A Nolita cocktail bar whose burger is an unexpectedly excellent bar bite — a ...
12Cubby'sManhattan84%A Hell's Kitchen neighborhood spot serving a straightforward, well-made burge...
13P.J. Clarke'sNew York$$$81%The legendary Midtown saloon since 1884, whose classic burger — a thick, juic...
14Old John's DinerNew York$$80%An Upper West Side diner whose honest, well-made burger satisfies the neighbo...
15Schnipper'sNew York$$80%A Midtown quick-service spot whose burger features a well-seasoned patty with...
16Lovely DayNew York$$79%A Nolita café with a pan-Asian menu whose burger is an off-script crowd-pleas...
17Lure FishbarNew York$$$79%A SoHo seafood brasserie whose burger features a high-quality beef patty with...
18Virgil's Real BBQ - NYCNew York$$$77%A Times Square BBQ spot whose smoked burger combines smoky, well-seasoned bee...
19ABC KitchenNew York$$$77%Jean-Georges Vongerichten's Flatiron farm-to-table restaurant, where the gras...

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best hamburger in Manhattan?+
According to Savor's aggregated critic and diner reviews, Aunt Jake's ranks #1 for best hamburger in Manhattan with a Savor Score of 93%.
How does Savor rank hamburger?+
Savor aggregates reviews from professional food critics, major publications, and audience platforms to calculate a Savor Score (0–100%) for each restaurant's hamburger. The score weights critic mentions, sentiment analysis, and diner ratings to produce a single, comparable ranking.
How many hamburger spots are ranked in Manhattan?+
Savor currently ranks 19 hamburger spots in Manhattan. Rankings are updated regularly as new reviews are published.

Related Rankings

🍗
Best Fried Chicken
#1 Charles Pan-Fried
🍜
Best Ramen
#1 Ichiran
🍜
Best Pho
#1 Hanoi House
🍗
Best Chicken Parm
#1 Parm
🦞
Best Lobster Roll
#1 Luke's Lobster
🍜
Best Beef Noodle Soup
#1 Lanzhou Handmade
← View all 2026 rankings