Best Fish Tacos in Manhattan

Based on 0 critic and audience reviews analyzed across Manhattan

Crispy, fresh, and topped with creamy slaw. Fish tacos bring the beach to the city.

fish-tacos
Make it at home →
2026 Best Dish Honorees
View all rankings →
#1
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

Dame

87 MacDougal St, New York, NY, 10012
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A tiny MacDougal Street seafood spot whose fish tacos feature pristine, lightly battered fish with a tangy slaw and punchy salsa — a deceptively simple dish executed at the highest level.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
91%
412 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#2
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

Yellow Rose

102 3rd Ave, New York, NY, 10003
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

An East Village Texan-inspired restaurant whose fish tacos deliver crispy, beer-battered fish with fresh cabbage slaw and a zesty crema that balances indulgence with brightness.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
88%
387 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#3
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

Taqueria Al Pastor

1966 3rd Ave, New York, NY, 10029
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

An East Harlem taquería serving fish tacos with tender, well-seasoned fish and bright, crunchy toppings on warm corn tortillas that reflect authentic Mexican street food tradition.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
87%
356 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#4
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

Cosme

35 E 21st St, New York, NY 10010
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

Enrique Olvera's Flatiron Mexican restaurant, where the fish tacos showcase pristine seafood with delicate preparations and refined salsas that elevate the taco to fine-dining territory.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
85%
298 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#5
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

Atla

372 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10012
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

The casual sibling of Cosme, serving vibrant Mexican fare in NoHo — the fish tacos feature fresh, lightly prepared fish with bright salsas and a modern sensibility.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
83%
276 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#6
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

Tacombi

255 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A multi-location Mexican café serving crowd-pleasing fish tacos with crispy, well-battered fish, fresh slaw, and a tangy chipotle crema on warm tortillas.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
80%
253 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#7
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

La Palapa

77 St Marks Pl, New York, NY 10003
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A St.View more →

2026 SAVOR SCORE
78%
234 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#8
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

Taco Taco

177 Orchard St, New York, NY, 10002
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A Lower East Side taquería serving straightforward fish tacos with a crispy batter and tangy slaw on warm corn tortillas — unpretentious and satisfying.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
77%
218 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#9
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

El Vez

259 Vesey St, New York, NY 10282
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

A Brookfield Place Mexican restaurant from Stephen Starr, whose fish tacos pair crispy, beer-battered fish with zingy toppings in a vibrant waterfront setting.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
75%
197 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#10
fish-tacos
Fish Tacosat

Playa Bettys

320 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023
SAVOR'S SUMMARY

An East Village beach-themed spot serving laid-back fish tacos with a crispy batter, fresh slaw, and a squeeze of lime — a fun, casual bite for the Avenue A crowd.

2026 SAVOR SCORE
73%
169 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
fish-tacos
Been on a fish tacos crawl?

Rate each spot to track your progress and build your personal ranking.

Behind the Dish
Dame
#1 Fish Tacos in Manhattan
Coming Soon

Full Rankings at a Glance

#RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreKnown For
1DameGreenwich Village91%A tiny MacDougal Street seafood spot whose fish tacos feature pristine, light...
2Yellow RoseNew York88%An East Village Texan-inspired restaurant whose fish tacos deliver crispy, be...
3Taqueria Al PastorNew York87%An East Harlem taquería serving fish tacos with tender, well-seasoned fish an...
4CosmeNew York85%Enrique Olvera's Flatiron Mexican restaurant, where the fish tacos showcase p...
5AtlaNew York83%The casual sibling of Cosme, serving vibrant Mexican fare in NoHo — the fish ...
6TacombiNew York80%A multi-location Mexican café serving crowd-pleasing fish tacos with crispy, ...
7La PalapaNew York78%A St.
8Taco TacoNew York77%A Lower East Side taquería serving straightforward fish tacos with a crispy b...
9El VezNew York75%A Brookfield Place Mexican restaurant from Stephen Starr, whose fish tacos pa...
10Playa BettysNew York73%An East Village beach-themed spot serving laid-back fish tacos with a crispy ...

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best fish tacos in Manhattan?+
According to Savor's aggregated critic and diner reviews, Dame ranks #1 for best fish tacos in Manhattan with a Savor Score of 91%.
How does Savor rank fish tacos?+
Savor aggregates reviews from professional food critics, major publications, and audience platforms to calculate a Savor Score (0–100%) for each restaurant's fish tacos. The score weights critic mentions, sentiment analysis, and diner ratings to produce a single, comparable ranking.
How many fish tacos spots are ranked in Manhattan?+
Savor currently ranks 10 fish tacos spots in Manhattan. Rankings are updated regularly as new reviews are published.

Related Rankings

🌮
Best Birria Tacos
#1 Birria-Landia
🍝
Best Linguine Vongole
#1 Carbone
🧆
Best Falafel
#1 Mamoun's
🦞
Best Lobster Roll
#1 Luke's Lobster
🥖
Best Banh Mi
#1 Banh Mi Saigon
🥪
Best Chicken Sandwich
#1 Fuku
← View all 2026 rankings