Best Lobster Roll in New Haven

Based on 0 critic and audience reviews analyzed across New Haven

Butter or mayo? Cold or hot? Manhattan's lobster roll debate has no wrong answer.

lobster-roll
Make it at home →
Best Dish Honorees
View all rankings →
#1
lobster-roll
Lobster Rollat

Caseus Fromagerie Bistro

SAVOR'S SUMMARY

Critics place Caseus Fromagerie Bistro among the top stops for Lobster Roll in New Haven, praising the consistent quality and execution that defines its standing.View more →

SAVOR SCORE
90%
50 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#2
lobster-roll
Lobster Rollat

Zinc Restaurant

SAVOR'S SUMMARY

Food writers single out Zinc Restaurant for its Lobster Roll, praising the consistent quality and execution that defines its standing.View more →

SAVOR SCORE
88%
50 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#3
lobster-roll
Lobster Rollat

Miya's Sushi (unique)

SAVOR'S SUMMARY

The Lobster Roll at Miya's Sushi (unique) draws consistent critical praise, with traditional preparation fidelity that has earned it a loyal following.View more →

SAVOR SCORE
86%
50 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#4
lobster-roll
Lobster Rollat

116 Crown

SAVOR'S SUMMARY

Critics praise 116 Crown's approach to Lobster Roll, with traditional preparation fidelity that has earned it a loyal following.View more →

SAVOR SCORE
80%
50 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
#5
lobster-roll
Lobster Rollat

Ordinary restaurant

SAVOR'S SUMMARY

Critics place Ordinary restaurant among the top stops for Lobster Roll in New Haven, with depth of flavor and balance that has earned it a loyal following.View more →

SAVOR SCORE
80%
50 reviews analyzed
YOUR SCORE
0%
Sign in to score
lobster-roll
Been on a lobster roll crawl?

Rate each spot to track your progress and build your personal ranking.

Behind the Dish
Caseus Fromagerie Bistro
#1 Lobster Roll in New Haven
Coming Soon

Full Rankings at a Glance

#RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreKnown For
1Caseus Fromagerie Bistro90%Critics place Caseus Fromagerie Bistro among the top stops for Lobster Roll i...
2Zinc Restaurant88%Food writers single out Zinc Restaurant for its Lobster Roll, praising the co...
3Miya's Sushi (unique)86%The Lobster Roll at Miya's Sushi (unique) draws consistent critical praise, w...
4116 Crown80%Critics praise 116 Crown's approach to Lobster Roll, with traditional prepara...
5Ordinary restaurant80%Critics place Ordinary restaurant among the top stops for Lobster Roll in New...

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best lobster roll in New Haven?+
According to Savor's aggregated critic and diner reviews, Caseus Fromagerie Bistro ranks #1 for best lobster roll in New Haven with a Savor Score of 90%.
How does Savor rank lobster roll?+
Savor aggregates reviews from professional food critics, major publications, and audience platforms to calculate a Savor Score (0–100%) for each restaurant's lobster roll. The score weights critic mentions, sentiment analysis, and diner ratings to produce a single, comparable ranking.
How many lobster roll spots are ranked in New Haven?+
Savor currently ranks 5 lobster roll spots in New Haven. Rankings are updated regularly as new reviews are published.

Related Rankings

🍗
Best Fried Chicken
#1 Charles Pan-Fried
🍣
Best Sushi
#1 Sushi Yasuda
🍝
Best Linguine Vongole
#1 Carbone
🍔
Best Hamburger
#1 JG Melon
🌮
Best Fish Tacos
#1 Los Tacos No. 1
🥪
Best Chicken Sandwich
#1 Fuku
← View all rankings